The Grumman Tracker, Trader, & Tracer

v2.1.0 / 01 jun 15 / greg goebel

* The Grumman S2F "Tracker" was one of the more prominent tools of Western naval power in the 1960s. This compact carrier-based aircraft provided a capable platform for ocean patrol and sub-hunting, and also served as the basis for the "Trader" transport and "Tracer" early-warning aircraft. This document provides a history and description of the Tracker, Trader, and Tracer -- as well as its predecessor in Navy service, the Grumman A2F "Guardian".

Grumman C-1A Trader



* The Grumman company developed a number of aircraft that made major contributions to Allied victory in World War II, one being the "TBM Avenger" torpedo bomber. In 1942, the US Naval Bureau of Aeronautics asked the Grumman company about a possible successor bomber. Further discussions led Grumman to initiate development of such a replacement in 1944, to be designated "XTB2F-1". The XTB2F-1 would eventually lead to the Guardian, but through a convoluted path.

The initial concept for the XTB2F-1 was for a multi-seat, carrier-based torpedo bomber with twin Pratt & Whitney (P&W) R-2800-22 Double Wasp radial engines. The XTB2F-1 would be able to carry up to 3,600 kilograms (8,000 pounds) of bombs or torpedoes, and would have an extremely long range of up to 5,950 kilometers (3,700 miles). Unfortunately, the XTB2F-1 proved far too ambitious: the design was simply too big and heavy to be flown off most of the US Navy's aircraft carriers. The XTB2F-1 was canceled in January 1945 in favor of a more conservation option, a derivative of the Grumman F7F Tigercat twin-engine fighter designated the "XTSF-1".

Grumman had also been working on a third design, with the company designation "G-70", for several months, and the Navy found the G-70 attractive. In February 1945 the service decided to abandon the XTSF-1, awarding a contract to Grumman for three G-70 prototypes, with the Navy designation "XTB3F". Two of the prototypes would be "XTB3F-1s" and the third would be an "XTB3F-2". They were to be "mixed-power" aircraft, with a P&W R-2800-6 Double Wasp, providing 1,715 kW (2,300 HP) and fitted in the nose; plus a turbojet fitted in the tail, fed by oval intakes in the leading edges of the wings. The turbojet was to be used to provide boost power for takeoffs and combat emergencies.

The XTB3F-1 would be fitted with a Westinghouse 19XB-2B turbojet, while the XTB3F-2 was to be fitted with a with a Westinghouse 24C-4B turbojet. The two aircraft were otherwise similar, featuring a crew of two, sitting side-by-side; a warload of up to 1,800 kilograms (4,000 pounds) of bombs, torpedoes, or rockets; and twin fixed forward-firing 20-millimeter cannon.

* The initial XTB3F-1 prototype flew on 19 December 1945, with Grumman test pilot Pat Gallo at the controls. The turbojet intakes were masked off because of problems encountered in ground tests; in fact, the jet engine proved to be a bad idea, and was quickly removed without ever being lit up in flight.

On 24 December, the Navy decided that they no longer needed a new torpedo bomber -- it was a generally obsolete concept by that time -- and told Grumman that they wanted a carrier-based antisubmarine warfare (ASW) aircraft instead. The Navy's mainstay in that role was an ASW modification of the Avenger, but something better was desired. There was no way at the time to cram all the necessary ASW gear into a single aircraft, and so two variants of the "Guardian", as it was named, were planned, with the pair to act as a "hunter-killer" team.

The two unbuilt prototypes were adapted towards this end. The single XTB3F-2 prototype was built as the "hunter" member of the team -- without the Westinghouse turbojet engine, but with two more seats for radar operators plus a large ventral radome fitted where the bombbay had been, accommodating AN/APS-20 ocean search radar. This aircraft became the "XTB3F-1S", and first flew on 1 October 1948. The second XTB3F-1 prototype was built as the "killer" member of the team, retaining the bombbay but deleting the cannon, adding a third seat, and being fitted with a searchlight as well as short-range radar. This aircraft became the "XTB3F-2S" and first flew in January 1949, with both aircraft performing naval flight tests in February.

Grumman AF-2W & AF-2S Guardian

By this time, the Guardian had already been ordered into production. The XTB3F-1S "hunter" was built as "AF-2W" (originally "AF-1S"), and the XTB3F-2S "killer" was built as the "AF-2S". The first production AF-2S Guardian flew on 17 November 1949. Qualification trials were conducted from May 1950 through November 1951, with the first operational aircraft going into service in October 1950.

* The Guardian was a brute of an aircraft, said to be the biggest single-engine piston aircraft ever flown by the US Navy. It was driven by a P&W R-2800-48W Double Wasp radial engine, providing 1,790 kW (2,400 HP) to an oversized four-bladed propeller.

The aircraft had taildragger landing gear, the main gear retracting outward into the wings, with a stinger-type arresting hook aft of the tailwheel. It had wide-span mid-mounted wings that folded back towards the tail in classic Grumman fashion, outside of the main landing gear. The tail was of conventional configuration, except for secondary vertical "finlets" mounted a little beyond the midpoint of each tailplane.

The AF-2W "hunter" or "guppy" member of the team had a crew of four and was unarmed, though it could carry underwing drop tanks, and had a large radome for the AN/APS-20 search radar mounted on the belly under the cockpit. The finlets were to provide lateral stability, which was affected by the radome. 153 AF-2W Guardians were built.

Grumman AF-2W & AF-2S Guardian

The AF-2S "killer" or "scrapper" member of the team had a crew of three and could carry up to 1,800 kilograms (4,000 pounds) of munitions, including depth charges, bombs, or a homing torpedo in the bombbay; fuel tanks or other stores on an underwing pylon inboard on each wing; and six 12.7 centimeter (5 inch) "high velocity air rockets (HVARs)" mounted on underwing stubs. It could also drop sonar buoys ("sonobuoys"), either from the bombbay or from an underwing pod. The AF-2S mounted AN/APS-30 targeting radar in a pod under the right wing and a searchlight in a pod under the left wing. The AF-2S retained the tail finlets -- though whether they were actually necessary or were simply there to ease production is an interesting little question. 193 AF-2S Guardians were built.

   _____________________   _________________   _______________________
   spec                    metric              english
   _____________________   _________________   _______________________

   wingspan                18.5 meters         60 feet 8 inches
   wing area               51 sq_meters        549 sq_feet
   length                  13.2 meters         43 feet 4 inches
   height                  4.93 meters         16 feet 2 inches

   empty weight            6,615 kilograms     14,580 pounds
   max loaded weight       11,340 kilograms    25,000 pounds

   maximum speed           507 KPH             315 MPH / 275 KT
   service ceiling         9,900 meters        32,500 feet
   range                   2,415 kilometers    1,500 MI / 1,305 NMI
   _____________________   _________________   _______________________

A second version of the AF-2S hunter was built beginning in 1952, featuring "magnetic anomaly detector (MAD)" gear with a boom that extended from a fairing mounted on the right side of the rear fuselage. The MAD gear greatly improved the Guardian's ability to find and track subs. This variant was designated the "AF-3S", and 40 were built. The last Guardian was rolled out in March 1953, with a total of 389 of all variants built, including the prototypes.

The Guardian was somewhat underpowered, an unfortunate feature for a carrier aircraft that had to make short takeoffs, and its pilots found its controls heavy. Its accident rate was on the high side -- by modern standards the unacceptably high side, but in an era when combat aircraft were cheaper and more common, accident rates that would be completely outrageous now were regarded as acceptable.

Grumman AF-2S Guardian

Although the Guardian conducted war patrols in Korean waters from March 1951 through May 1953, it did not remain in service for long after that; the last Guardian was retired from first-line service on 31 August 1955. Guardians remained in service with Navy Reserve squadrons into 1957. A number of Guardians ended up in civilian hands and were often used as "water bombers", with a water / retardant tank in a ventral tub, and some of these aircraft are now on static display in museums. For example, one AF-2S is on show at the Naval Aviation Museum in Pensacola, Florida. It appears no Guardians remain in flightworthy condition.



* The Guardian was an interim aircraft in the carrier ASW role; the Navy had begun work on a much better successor even before the AF entered operational service. On 30 June 1950, the US Navy awarded Grumman a contract to develop a twin-engine carrier-based aircraft that could perform all the functions of the Guardian duo.

The contract specified development of two prototypes of the Grumman "Model 89", with the initial military designation of "XS2F-1 Sentinel". The XS2F-1 was to carry a full complement of ASW sensors and weapons, and fly with good cruising speed over a range of up to 1,600 kilometers (1,000 miles).

The first XS2F-1 flew on 4 December 1952. It was a high-wing monoplane with a rounded, roomy fuselage, powered by twin Wright R-1820-82WA Cyclone nine-cylinder air-cooled radial engines providing 1,120 kW (1,500 HP) each, mounted in long nacelles on the wings. The XS2F-1's long wings and powerful engines allowed it to operate from small carriers and short airfields. The wings folded up hydraulically over the top of the aircraft, with the wing fold "skewed" so the two wings would overlap each other when folded. The XS2F-1 had tricycle landing gear, with twin-wheel nose gear, along with single-wheel main gear retracting backwards into the engine nacelles. The aircraft was fitted with a stinger-type arresting hook, preceded by a small tailwheel to act as a bumper on carrier landings.

The XS2F-1's ASW fit included sonobuoy ejector tubes, with eight built into the rear of each engine nacelle, and firing straight out the back; a 70-million-candlepower searchlight mounted on the right wing; an AN/APS-38 search radar in a retractable ventral "dustbin" radome, behind the weapons bay; an AN/APA-69 electronics countermeasures (ECM) antenna in a teardrop fairing above the cockpit; and a retractable AN/ASQ-10 MAD boom in the tail.

The XS2F-1 carried a crew of four, with the pilot on the left, co-pilot / navigator on the right, and two systems operators in the rear. The XS2F-1 had an internal fuel capacity of 1,970 liters (520 US gallons). Total weapons load was up to 2,180 kilograms (4,800 pounds), including a single homing torpedo in the weapons bay, plus depth charges, rockets, bombs, or other stores fitted to six underwing pylons.

* Following trials of 15 "YS2F-1" service evaluation machines, the production "S2F-1" entered US Navy service in February 1954, with Squadron VS-26. The S2F-1 was much like the XS2F-1 prototypes, but had uprated Cyclones providing 1,138 kW (1,525 HP) each. After service introduction, the type was later renamed "Tracker". Although aircraft nicknames are something of a treacherous subject, occasionally being fabrications well after the fact, it does appear that the Tracker eventually became known as the "Stoof", a corruption of the "S-Two-F" designation.

Grumman S2F-1 (S-2A) Tracker

A total of 740 S2F-1s was built by Grumman, not counting the YS2F-1 evaluation machines, with de Havilland of Canada (DHC) building an additional 43 "CS2F-1"s, with minor differences in equipment fit. The S2F-1 / CS2F-1 was built in larger quantities than all successive variants and derivatives of the type combined.

* The US Navy relied heavily on the Tracker for fleet defense, and took measures to keep the type up to date. Many USN Trackers were retrofitted with the AN/AQA-3 "Jezebel" acoustic search (passive sonar) and "Julie" echo-ranging (active sonar) gear, and redesignated "S2F-1S". The Julie system involved fitting ejector tubes for echo-sounding explosive charges in the bottom of the rear fuselage.

The next production model, the "S2F-2", featured a protruding and offset weapons bay to accommodate an oversized nuclear depth charge, plus an enlarged tailplane to compensate for the resulting aerodynamic changes. The swollen weapons bay gave the S2F-2 a slightly pregnant look. A total of 77 S2F-2s was built by Grumman, with an additional 57 similar "CS2F-2" machines built by DHC.

* The "G-121 / S2F-3" first flew on 21 May 1959, and featured:

The S2F-3 was bigger overall to provide more crew space, fuel capacity, and equipment load. The S2F-3 entered fleet service in May 1961.

Since smaller nuclear depth charges had been developed, the weapons bay was shrunk back to its original size. The ECM antenna fairing on top of the cockpit was removed, replaced by an improved ECM system using antennas fitted into the wingtips, and most of the other electronics systems were modernized as well. Stores pylons were strengthened, and the sonobuoy compartments at the end of the nacelles were noticeably enlarged to increase sonobuoy capacity from 8 to 16 in each nacelle. 100 S2F-3s were built in all.

   _____________________   _________________   _______________________
   spec                    metric              english
   _____________________   _________________   _______________________

   wingspan                22.12 meters        72 feet 7 inches
   wing area               46.08 sq_meters     496 sq_feet
   length                  13.26 meters        43 feet 6 inches
   height                  5.05 meters         16 feet 7 inches

   empty weight            8,500 kilograms     18,750 pounds
   max loaded weight       13,220 kilograms    29,150 pounds

   maximum speed           426 KPH             265 MPH / 230 KT
   service ceiling         6,400 meters        21,000 feet
   range                   2,090 kilometers    1,300 MI / 1,130 NMI
   endurance               9 hours
   _____________________   _________________   _______________________

The final production variant of the Tracker was the "S2F-3S", essentially an S2F-3 with Julie-Jezebel gear and a TACAN radio navigation beacon receiver system. The last of 252 S2F-3s was delivered in 1968, and were the last of a total of 1,284 Trackers built in the US and Canada.

A number of S2F-3S Trackers were later fitted with AN/AQA-7 sonobuoy processing gear and redesignated "S-2F", and apparently many S2F-1S aircraft were updated to the same or similar specification and given the same S-2F designation. There was also an upgrade of 50 S2F-3S machines with the designation "S-2G" to allow it to carry a pair of AGM-12 "Bullpup" radio-guided air-to-surface missiles. The copilot guided them using a joystick and watching a flare on the tail of the missile.

* A total of 20 US Navy squadrons was ultimately equipped with the Tracker. The type also did very well on the international market, with help from the US Military Assistance Program, being supplied to Argentina, Australia, Brazil, France, Italy, Japan, the Netherlands, Taiwan, Thailand, Turkey, and Uruguay.



* With such a large number of Trackers built, it wasn't surprising that many airframes were modified for other purposes:

When the US military consolidated aircraft designation schemes in 1962, the different Tracker variants were redesignated as follows:


   S2F-1:    S-2A
   S2F-1T:   TS-2A
   S2F-1S:   S-2B
   S2F-2:    S-2C
   S2F-2P:   RS-2C
   S2F-2U:   US-2C
   S2F-3:    S-2D
   S2F-3U:   US-2D
   S2F-3S:   S-2E

Canadian Trackers were given a service-life update in the mid-1960s, with substantial system updates, and redesignated "CP-121" when the Canadian Armed Forces were created by service consolidation in early 1968.

* The Tracker served with the US Navy with quiet distinction during the 1960s. Along with its primary role to protect the fleet from Soviet submarines, it was used for maritime patrol during the Vietnam War, assisting in rescues of aircrew downed at sea and occasionally engaging North Vietnamese patrol boats using unguided rockets, fired from underwing pods. One Tracker was lost to enemy action. Its non-combat losses were also low, and in fact the Tracker had an enviable safety record.

* The Tracker was replaced by the Lockheed S-3 Viking in first-line operation in the 1970s, and the last operational Tracker, an ES-2D, was phased out in the mid-1980s. The type remained in use with a number of international air arms for much longer. Although it was obsolete in the ASW role by the time it ended production, it was still an effective aircraft for maritime patrol to monitor surface shipping, and at last notice was still being operated in declining numbers in this role by various countries.

It also remains in use as a popular "water bomber" to fight forest fires, with Trackers modified to carry 3,032 liters (800 US gallons) of fire retardant. One of the primary users is the California Department of Forestry (CDF), but other Tracker water bomber conversions have been performed for Canada and Turkey. Although the Tracker is a capable and rugged aircraft, its stubby fuselage does make it difficult to handle in turbulence, particularly after retardant release, and a number of CDF pilots have lost their lives in crashes.

Turbo Tracker fire bomber

Maintaining the old Wright Cyclones is becoming increasingly difficult, and so "Turbo Tracker" conversions have become popular. The engines of choice are the Garrett TPE331 or the Pratt & Whitney Canada (PWC) PT6A turboprop, both typically rated at 1,225 kW (1,645 SHP), and conversions have been performed by a number of companies:

While most Trackers are far from the end of their airframe lives, a tribute to the traditional ruggedness of Grumman designs, military Turbo Tracker conversions have not been as popular as expected. Older versions of the P-3 Orion are now available on the international used-aircraft market, and buyers prefer the more capacious and longer-legged Orion over the Tracker.



* In 1955, Grumman flew the prototype of the "G-96 / TF-1 Trader" "carrier onboard delivery" (COD) derivative of the Tracker. The Trader featured a modified fuselage, but was otherwise parts-compatible with the Tracker. The Trader could be fitted with easily-removed seats for nine passengers, and included front and rear sliding bulkheads mounted on rails, plus removeable posts, to secure cargo for carrier landings. Maximum cargo capacity was 3,855 kilograms (8,500 pounds). Life rafts were fitted into the rear of the engine nacelles.

Grumman TF-1 (C-1A) Trader

First flight of the Trader was in January 1955, with initial service delivery in 1957. A total of 87 was built from 1955 into 1958, including four fitted for the ECM role and given the designation "TF-1Q". In 1962, the TF-1 was given the new designation of "C-1A", and the TF-1Q was redesignated "EC-1A". The Trader served with three US Navy logistics support and transport squadrons -- but it was strictly an interim type, being replaced by the Grumman C-2 Greyhound.

Some Traders ended up in civilian hands, and in 2011 the Brazilian Navy bought eight C-1As for use in the COD and tanker roles on the carrier SAO PAULO -- these machines apparently having been obtained from mothballed aircraft. They were to be refurbished, with modernized avionics, and re-engined with Honeywell TPE331 turboprops driving five-bladed props. The program stalled, but in 2015, work began on upgrade of four machines, with Marsh Aviation upgrading the engines, while Elbit of Israel provides a glass cockpit, plus modern communications and navigation kit, as well as a new environmental control system. The "KC-2s", as they will be known, will be capable of mid-air refueling, and will be able to act as tankers, along with their COD services. They will fly off the carrier SAO PAULO.

* The Trader led in turn to another Tracker derivative, the "G-117 / WF-2 Tracer" airborne early-warning (AEW) variant. The Tracer started life as a proposal to the Navy in 1951 for the "XWF-1", resulting in a contract for two prototypes of an AEW machine based on the Tracker -- but all that was built was a partial mockup, the program being canceled in 1953. The program was revived in 1955, with Grumman proposing an AEW aircraft based on the Trader instead of the Tracker. A Trader was used as an aerodynamic prototype, performing its initial flight on 17 December 1956. The first production WF-2 performed its initial flight on 1 March 1958, with a total of 88 built into 1961.

Grumman WF-2 (E-1B) Tracer

The Tracer featured a large dorsal "saucer" radome made of honeycomb fiberglass, with dimensions of 6.1 by 9.14 meters (20 by 30 feet), to accommodate the antenna for its Hazeltine AN/APS-82 search radar, and a new tail unit with three tailfins to compensate for the wake interference of the radome. Since the radome blocked the wings from folding upward, they were redesigned to fold backward along the fuselage in classic Grumman fashion.

   _____________________   _________________   _______________________
   spec                    metric              english
   _____________________   _________________   _______________________

   wingspan                22.12 meters        72 feet 7 inches
   wing area               46.08 sq_meters     496.0 sq_feet
   length                  13.82 meters        45 feet 4 inches
   height                  5.13 meters         16 feet 10 inches

   empty weight            9,535 kilograms     21,025 pounds
   max loaded weight       12,230 kilograms    26,970 pounds

   maximum speed           385 KPH             240 MPH / 205 KT
   cruise speed            265 KPH             165 MPH / 140 KT
   service ceiling         4,800 meters        15,800 feet
   range                   1,665 kilometers    1,035 MI / 900 NMI
   endurance               6.8 hours
   _____________________   _________________   _______________________

The aircraft also featured a identification friend or foe (IFF) interrogator to determine if targets were friendly or hostile, plus a "Bellhop" system to transfer radar data to a surface vessel, and a communications relay transponder. The Tracer had a crew of four, including pilot, copilot, and two radar operators.

Grumman WF-2 Tracer

The Tracer was known as "Willie Fudd" by crews, in reference to its designation code, and sometimes as "Stoof With A Roof". The WF-2 was redesignated "E-1B" in 1962. Like the Trader, the Tracer was an interim type, being replaced by the Grumman E-2 Hawkeye from the late 1960s, with the last Willie Fudd retired in 1977.



* The following table gives Tracker / Trader / Tracer variants, and production quantities:

   variant        built  mod  notes

   XS2F-1             2        Initial prototypes.
   YS2F-1            15        Service evaluation machines.
   S2F-1 (S-2A)     740        Initial & main production variant.
   CS2F-1            43        DHC-built S2F-1.
   S2F-1S (S-2B)      -    ?   S2F-1 with improved ASW kit.
   S2F-2 (S-2C)      77        Bulged bombbay for nuke depth charges.
   CS2F-2            57        DHC-built S2F-2.
   S2F-3 (S-2D)     100        "Stretched" Tracker. 
   S2F-3S (S-2E)    255        S2F-3 with improved ASW kit.

   S-2F               -     ?  S2F-1 & S2F-3S with new avionics.
   S2F-1T (TS-2A)     -   200  S2F-1 multi-engine trainer.
   US-2A              -    51  S2F-1 transport / target tug.
   US-2B              -    75  S2F-1 utility aircraft.
   S2F-2P (RS-2C)     -     1  S2F-2 photo-reconnaissance conversion.
   S2F-2U (US-2C)     -     ?  S2F-2 transport conversions.
   S2F-3U (US-2D)     -    54  S2F-3 transport conversions.
   ES-2D              -     7  S2F-3 range control conversions.
   S-2G               -    50  S2F-3S with Bullpup ASM capability.
   CP-121             -     ?  Canadian Tracker updates.

   sum            1,289

   TF-1 (C-1A)       83        Trader COD aircraft.
   TF-1Q (EC-1A)      4        Trader EW aircraft.

   sum               87

   WF-1               1        Tracer AEW prototype.
   WF-2 (E-1B)       88        Production Tracer.

   sum               89

   TOTAL          1,465

As usual, there may be minor discrepancies in this count, but it can be regarded as well in the ballpark.

* One of the might-have-beens of the Tracker story was consideration of its use as a gunship in Vietnam. The idea wasn't ridiculous, the Lockheed P2V Neptune having seen some use as a "jungle fighter" in the conflict. The Air Force was looking for a "Self Contained Night Attack (SNCA)" platform that could locate targets on its own at night and engage them; the Tracker seemed to have the payload capability to do the job.

The gunship Tracker was to be designated the "AS-2D". It was to be fitted with "forward looking infrared (FLIR)" and "low light level TV (LLLTV)" sensors to obtain targets, with the Tracker's standard searchlight slaved to the LLLTV. Weapons were to consist of cluster munitions dispensers in the bombbay and stores carried on the underwing pylons. Two "YAS-2D" evaluation machines were planned, but the effort ran into technical and organizational difficulties, with the Air Force pulling the plug on the exercise in early 1968.

Turbo Tracker

* Sources include:

The "S-2F Tracker" website in the Netherlands was a significant source of information as well, and some minor details were obtained from the 1960 edition of JANE'S ALL THE WORLD AIRCRAFT. The information on Brazilian Trackers was provided by Captain Marcio Jansen Calvacanti of the Brazilian Navy.

* As concerns copyrights and permissions for this document, all illustrations and images credited to me are public domain. I reserve all rights to my writings. However, if anyone does want to make use of my writings, just contact me, and we can chat about it. I'm lenient in giving permissions, usually on the basis of being properly credited.

* Revision history:

   v1.0   / 01 mar 01 
   v1.0.1 / 01 jan 02 / Review & polish.
   v1.0.2 / 01 jan 04 / Review & polish.
   v1.0.3 / 01 jan 06 / Review & polish.
   v1.0.4 / 01 dec 07 / Review & polish.
   v1.0.5 / 01 jun 09 / AS-2D gunship comments.
   v1.0.6 / 01 may 11 / Review & polish.
   v1.0.7 / 01 apr 13 / Brazilian Traders.
   v2.0.0 / 01 jul 13 / Folded in AF Guardian.
   v2.1.0 / 01 jun 15 / Reorganization.

The section on the AF Guardian started out as a separate document, the initial version being released in December 2000, with the writeup having reached version v1.0.6 before it was added to this document in July 2013.